As we hurtle ever closer to an irreversible climate disaster I grow increasingly sceptical of the likelihood of Green politicians being able to deliver the radical changes we need via the electoral process before it is all too late. It is true that this year’s local elections have seen well documented Green gains across the country, and the party has rightfully been celebrating this. However, to be brutally honest it’s not enough. If there is any chance of a wave of Green politicians running local councils, or even forming a Westminster government, then I believe a new approach is needed in order to reach out the huge numbers of people who don’t bother to vote.
In the Leeds City Council local elections in May 2022 turnout across the city as a whole was 33.8%. In wards that could be described as more “working-class”, the percentage turnout was around the mid to high twenties, whilst in the more affluent or more rural areas the figures made the low to mid forties. In the Little London & Woodhouse ward turnout was as low as 16.3%. This apparent voter apathy has been something that has troubled me for many years, especially when canvassing for the Green Party and encountering people on the doorstep who say they are not voting, see no point in it, and claim that all the parties are just the same – just in it for themselves.
The video below by Grace Blakeley sets out some of the reasons why people are losing faith in democracy, particularly young people. Grace argues that the people in positions of power in our society simply don’t care about the voices of ordinary people, which is a view that I share. She also highlights that if we look at voter turnout since 1997, more and more working class voters dropped out of the electorate at every election, deciding there’s little point in voting. It’s worth a watch as Grace sets out a number of strong reasons for why the turnout has slumped in this way.
I concur with pretty much all of the the video content apart from Grace’s assertion that people’s views on climate, housing, or inequality are not currently represented anywhere in the political spectrum. These are clearly key campaign areas of the Green Party. However, at a broader level the video is a timely examination of the important subject of turnout, which is something I wanted to look at, and the crucial role it might play in Green Party strategy and electoral success.
Smaller political parties and independent candidates usually lack the resources of the two main parties in the UK. By resources I mean both funds and volunteers. As a result, and it’s certainly the case with the Green Party, electoral strategies are usually shaped by the availability of local resources, and therefore priorities have to be considered. This typically involves concentrating on a few key target wards as it is too expensive and labour intensive to leaflet or canvass all of them. Whilst several party leaflets may be delivered to all homes in one year in a target ward, the target canvassing is most likely done using “marked” electoral registers to direct most energy to those residents who actually regularly vote. In some cases where funds are short, leafleting may also be limited to certain parts of a ward where support is greatest.
I have to accept that there is some merit to this targeting strategy, after all it has been the basis of the Green Party’s successes across the country and certainly in the Farnley & Wortley ward in Leeds that up to this election had a full contingent of Green Party councillors. However, whilst during my early years as a Green Party member I accepted this approach as a sensible use of limited resources, I have grown to feel somewhat uneasy about it. Avoiding knocking on the doors of the regular non-voter does nothing towards engaging with the people who feel alienated from politics. Nor does it help us demonstrate that the Green Party is different, and that the party has policies that will genuinely improve their lives. In short it contributes to voter apathy and undermines democracy. The First Past the Post electoral system we still endure was fine for a two-party system, but it clearly disadvantages the smaller parties and the independent candidates. Given this electoral system, if the Green Party is to win significantly more seats both locally and nationally, then I feel it is imperative it adopts a strategy to reverse the decline in turnout by giving the disillusioned a reason to vote.
The election of the Green candidate Ed Carlisle in Leeds’ Hunslet & Riverside ward last month may point to the best approach to adopt. It has taken several years’ hard work to finally oust a long-standing Labour councillor, and in Ed the Greens had an excellent candidate who was extremely active and well known in the local community. Building relationships and networks with other active community groups is an important way forward as not only does it demonstrate the party’s commitment to the local community, but it expands the number of people who see what good things are being done, hear what the party stands for, and potentially gains active volunteers or members. Currently young people’s concerns are pretty much ignored by the two main parties, and the enthusiasm they demonstrated when Labour was led by Corbyn seems to have disappeared under the leadership of Starmer. Reaching out more to younger people must also be a key aim in the bid to increase voter turnout.
One final strategy is a combined promotion of both the Green Party’s local activism and the national policies that are going to make a significant difference to people’s lives. Moreover the party must clearly demonstrate that the policies to tackle climate change will not cost people more, but in fact give them more money in their pocket. For example home insulation or regulating bus services will reduce the overall carbon footprint whilst saving people money. Other policies like the Citizen’s Income, or the quality jobs created by a Green New Deal should hopefully strike a chord with people facing up to the current horrors of the cost of living crisis. It might even persuade the regular non-voter to see the Green Party as a party worth voting for.