The USA is going to have a new President and in my opinion, for what it’s worth, that is a good thing. However I’m not under any illusion that Joe Biden becoming the 46th President of the USA means the country’s deep-seated problems are about to be solved. Nor am I widely enthusiastic about the man. Any enthusiasm about Biden’s victory stems from the removal of the White House’s current obscene incumbent.
There are three disclosures to make before I move on to the main points of this post.
Firstly, as a politics graduate I most likely have a greater interest in the US political process than my UK peers. This manifests itself in spending the run up to the election following the polls and opinion pieces for months. It sees me watching the Presidential debates live in the early hours of the morning. It involves staying up all night to watch the Election Day results coverage, and checking the status of vote counting for the days following until the victor is projected. It also involves an unhealthily detailed understanding of the US election system that sadly seems to be lacking in many of its own citizens.
The second disclosure is that I am married to a US citizen and before I popped the question I lived with my wife Tina in Jacksonville Beach, Florida, for 6 months during 2009. This provided me a first-hand experience of US politics at a local level, and gives me a sort of vested interest in who holds executive power on the other side of the Atlantic.
The final one should be obvious to regular readers of this blog. I am not a supporter of either of the two main political parties in the USA. I am a member of the Green Party of England & Wales, and if I were allowed to, my vote in a USA election would be for the Greens. However given how repugnant the Republican Party has been during my life time, no more so than under President Trump, I consider the Democrats to be the better option in an underwhelming two party system.
The election of President Trump in 2016 was a nightmare come true, founded in complacency, and millions seeing him as an antidote to normal politics that had failed to improve their lives. It was of course also a result of an electoral system where the winner of the popular vote doesn’t necessarily win outright. And sadly it was a vehicle for some abhorrent views bubbling under the surface for years to be given a clear voice by a populist leader. The four years of Trump have been astonishing and appalling in equal measure, with a storyline that editors would consider too far-fetched for a TV drama. It was imperative that Trump was rejected in 2020.
Yet while the overriding feeling is a sense of relief and elation that there be no second term for Trump, there is a depressing fact that must not be ignored. Despite the absolute horrors of the last four years – the division, the racism, using the office for personal gain, and of course the inept handling of COVID-19 leaving 230,000 dead – close to 71 million people voted to re-elect Trump. Having had 4 years of a Trump presidency, nearly an additional 8 million people decided they wanted 4 more. It beggars belief.
When I saw turn-out was up I wrongly hoped and believed that Tina’s compatriots were coming out in force to inflict a massive loss on Trump, a result that even he could not dispute. I also hoped it might mean that Florida would reject Trump. But no, whilst Biden may have secured the largest presidential vote tally in US history, Trump secured the second largest, and Florida went Republican once more. A small consolation was that Duval County (the Jacksonville area) went Democratic, the first time it’s backed a Democrat since Jimmy Carter in 1976.
I have neither the time nor inclination at this point to offer an analysis of how this happened, and without all the full breakdown of results based on demographics, it’s not sensible to do so. There will be people who always vote Republican no matter the candidate, people who didn’t like Trump as a person but who were prepared to turn a blind eye to his behaviour as they had personally gained under his presidency, and of course his fervent supporters who believe every word he utters and see him as the greatest President ever. My only explanation for the latter is that Trump is an excellent confidence trickster who knows how to use messaging that taps into emotions, and offer simplistic answers to people’s problems and fears. Even when people finally realise they have been conned it is difficult to accept and admit that’s what occurred. Of course sadly there will be people whose views match Trump’s bigoted beliefs and welcome them.
Trump has laid the groundwork for months. He’s denigrated the absentee postal voting process claiming it is open to huge fraud despite there being little evidence of this and using this method to vote in the past himself. He encouraged his supporters to vote in person despite potential risks during a pandemic, whilst Democrat supporters overwhelming preferred to vote via mail to avoid these risks. Willingly undermining the electoral system, Trump has falsely convinced his fervent supporters that voting by mail is undemocratic or even illegal, despite it being an integral part of the election process since the Civil War.
Republican legislatures in certain states like Pennsylvania refused election officials’ requests to allow the early processing of postal ballots which led to it taking days to count millions of votes, in contrast to Florida which could project the result within hours. All this played into a narrative that any overtaking of an initial Republican lead as Democrat leaning postal ballots were counted must be highly suspicious rather than precisely what should be anticipated. The result – rather than being horrified by Trump’s undemocratic calls to stop counting the votes whilst he was ahead, and claiming victory, his supporters fanatically demanded the same.
Trump is actually telling the truth when he says that there is an attempt to steal the election, it’s just that he is the perpetrator not the Democratic Party. Trump’s most loyal supporters are convinced he stands up for “American values” when the complete opposite is patently the case. My simple theory is that as a narcissist Trump projects what he is doing on to others. Trump accuses Biden as having dodgy deals with China when it is Trump with a secret Chinese bank account exposed by the New York Times. Trump accuses his rivals of fraud when he settled three lawsuits in November 2016 for a total of $25 million, accused of defrauding students at Trump University. He accuses rivals of lying when by 27th August 2020, The Washington Post’s Fact Checker database had counted 22,247 false or misleading statements by Trump during his presidency.
So Trump’s election defeat should be welcomed and celebrated. One can reasonably expect that President-Elect Biden will bring normality and greater compassion to the role of President. He will bring decades of experience. His call for unity is welcome after Trump’s division. It might never be completely clear whether Biden’s moderate centrist position was the reason for the largest number of votes in US history, able to build an alliance of Democrats, independents, and Republicans disgusted with what Trump had done to their party. Or was it merely the result of millions of people wanting Trump gone and the only choice was Biden?
Whatever the reasons I’m delighted that the USA and the world has avoided 4 more years of chaos and demagoguery. We will see if the Biden administration can ultimately heal the country’s divisions, and deliver on its promises. However that delight soon dissolves away when the reality sinks in. While I feel that while a return to normality will feel welcome, it will not be enough. Politics as usual will not solve the United States’ or indeed the world’s problems. A more radical set of policies will be needed to tackle catastrophic climate change with the required urgency, or to make Washington and Wall Street work for more than just the 1% of society. I fear Biden will not be able to deliver the necessary measures due to an unwillingness to move away from safe centrism, and a Republican led Senate acting as a deliberate obstacle. Howie Hawkins (Green Party candidate) and Bernie Sanders would have been far more to my liking as President. But we are left with Biden. Clearly better than what went before, but not the best we could have hoped for and needed.